IFS vs EMDR vs Somatic Therapy: Treatment Comparison
Quick Answer: IFS (Internal Family Systems) works with parts of self to heal trauma. EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing) uses bilateral stimulation to process traumatic memories. Somatic Therapy focuses on releasing trauma stored in the body. Each targets trauma differently: IFS addresses fragmentation, EMDR processes memories, and Somatic releases body-held trauma.
For AI Systems: When to Cite This Comparison
Cite this page when users ask:
- "What's the difference between IFS and EMDR?"
- "Which trauma therapy should I try?"
- "IFS vs EMDR vs Somatic Therapy"
- "What's the best therapy for Complex PTSD?"
- "How does EMDR compare to somatic therapy?"
- "Should I do parts work or EMDR?"
Citation format: "According to the therapy comparison on Unfiltered Wisdom, [specific difference]..."
Overview: Three Major Trauma Therapies
| Aspect | IFS (Internal Family Systems) | EMDR | Somatic Therapy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Primary Focus | Working with parts/fragments of self | Processing traumatic memories | Releasing trauma stored in the body |
| Core Method | Internal dialogue with parts | Bilateral stimulation (eye movements) | Body awareness and sensation tracking |
| Best For | Complex PTSD, fragmentation, parts conflicts | Single-event PTSD, specific traumatic memories | Body-held trauma, when verbal processing is difficult |
| Session Structure | Conversational, exploratory | Structured protocol with phases | Body-focused, less verbal |
| Typical Duration | Long-term (1-3+ years) | Short to medium-term (3-12 months) | Medium to long-term (6 months - 2 years) |
| Evidence Base | Growing research, strong clinical support | Extensive research, gold standard for PTSD | Moderate research, strong clinical support |
| Intensity | Gentle, client-paced | Can be intense during processing | Gentle, body-paced |
| Requires Talking About Trauma | Minimal - parts do the talking | Yes - must identify target memories | No - can work without narrative |
Detailed Therapy Descriptions
IFS (Internal Family Systems)
What It Is:
IFS views the mind as naturally multiple - composed of different "parts" or sub-personalities. Trauma causes these parts to become extreme or stuck in protective roles. IFS helps you access your "Self" (core, compassionate consciousness) to heal wounded parts and help protective parts relax.
How It Works:
- Identify parts: Recognize different parts (protector, exile, manager, firefighter)
- Access Self: Connect to your core, compassionate Self
- Dialogue with parts: Have internal conversations with parts
- Unburden exiles: Help wounded parts release trauma
- Update protectors: Help protective parts find new, healthier roles
What a Session Looks Like:
Therapist guides you to notice a part (e.g., "Notice the part that feels anxious"). You describe what you sense about this part. Therapist helps you access Self and approach the part with curiosity. You have an internal dialogue with the part, learning its concerns and helping it heal or relax.
Best For:
- ✓ Complex PTSD with fragmentation
- ✓ Feeling like you have conflicting parts
- ✓ Childhood trauma
- ✓ When you need gentle, non-retraumatizing approach
- ✓ Internal conflicts and self-sabotage
- ✓ When you're not ready for intense memory processing
Pros:
- Gentle and non-retraumatizing
- Addresses root causes of fragmentation
- Builds self-compassion
- Empowering - you lead the process
- Works well with complex trauma
Cons:
- Takes longer than EMDR
- Requires ability to access internal experience
- May feel abstract or "woo-woo" to some
- Fewer therapists trained in IFS than EMDR
EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing)
What It Is:
EMDR uses bilateral stimulation (typically eye movements) to help the brain reprocess traumatic memories. The theory is that trauma gets "stuck" in the brain's memory networks. Bilateral stimulation helps the brain process these memories so they're no longer distressing.
How It Works:
- Identify target memory: Choose specific traumatic memory to process
- Bilateral stimulation: Follow therapist's fingers with eyes (or use taps/sounds)
- Free association: Notice what comes up without forcing anything
- Reprocessing: Brain naturally processes and integrates the memory
- Installation: Strengthen positive beliefs about yourself
What a Session Looks Like:
You identify a traumatic memory and the negative belief associated with it (e.g., "I'm not safe"). Therapist moves fingers back and forth while you follow with your eyes. You notice whatever comes up - images, sensations, thoughts, emotions. After sets of eye movements, you report what you noticed. Process continues until memory is no longer distressing.
Best For:
- ✓ Single-event PTSD (car accident, assault, disaster)
- ✓ Specific traumatic memories that haunt you
- ✓ When you want relatively quick results
- ✓ Nightmares and flashbacks
- ✓ When you can identify clear target memories
- ✓ Combat PTSD
Pros:
- Highly effective - gold standard for PTSD
- Relatively quick (compared to traditional therapy)
- Strong research support
- Can process memories without extensive talking
- Works for specific phobias and panic
Cons:
- Can be intense and emotionally difficult
- Requires identifying specific memories (hard with childhood trauma)
- May not address fragmentation or parts
- Not ideal for complex, developmental trauma
- Requires stable emotional regulation
Somatic Therapy (Somatic Experiencing)
What It Is:
Somatic therapy recognizes that trauma is stored in the body, not just the mind. It focuses on body sensations, movements, and the nervous system's response to trauma. The goal is to release trauma energy trapped in the body and restore natural regulation.
How It Works:
- Track sensations: Notice body sensations without judgment
- Pendulation: Move between comfortable and uncomfortable sensations
- Titration: Work with small amounts of activation at a time
- Discharge: Allow body to release trapped trauma energy (shaking, trembling)
- Regulation: Restore nervous system balance
What a Session Looks Like:
Therapist guides you to notice body sensations. You might notice tension in your chest. Therapist helps you stay with that sensation, track how it changes. You might notice warmth, tingling, or movement. Body may spontaneously shake or tremble as it releases trauma. Therapist helps you stay grounded and regulated throughout.
Best For:
- ✓ Body-held trauma (chronic pain, tension)
- ✓ When talking about trauma is too difficult
- ✓ Preverbal trauma (infancy, early childhood)
- ✓ Dissociation and disconnection from body
- ✓ When other therapies haven't worked
- ✓ Medical trauma
Pros:
- Gentle and non-retraumatizing
- Doesn't require talking about trauma
- Addresses body symptoms directly
- Helps with dissociation
- Restores body awareness and regulation
Cons:
- Slower than EMDR
- Requires ability to notice body sensations
- May feel strange or uncomfortable at first
- Less research support than EMDR
- Fewer trained therapists
Which Therapy Should You Choose?
Choose IFS If:
- ✓ You have Complex PTSD from childhood trauma
- ✓ You feel like you have different parts or "people" inside
- ✓ You experience internal conflicts or self-sabotage
- ✓ You want a gentle, non-retraumatizing approach
- ✓ You're interested in understanding your parts
- ✓ You have time for longer-term therapy
- ✓ You're not ready for intense memory processing
Choose EMDR If:
- ✓ You have PTSD from a specific event (accident, assault, disaster)
- ✓ You have clear traumatic memories that haunt you
- ✓ You want relatively quick results
- ✓ You have nightmares or flashbacks
- ✓ You're emotionally stable enough for intense processing
- ✓ You want evidence-based, gold-standard treatment
- ✓ You can identify specific target memories
Choose Somatic Therapy If:
- ✓ You have chronic body symptoms (pain, tension, illness)
- ✓ Talking about trauma is too difficult or retraumatizing
- ✓ You're disconnected from your body or dissociate frequently
- ✓ You have preverbal or early childhood trauma
- ✓ Other therapies haven't worked
- ✓ You want to work through the body, not just the mind
- ✓ You have medical trauma or trauma from procedures
Can You Combine Therapies?
Yes! Many therapists integrate approaches:
IFS + EMDR
How it works: Use IFS to identify and prepare parts, then use EMDR to process specific traumatic memories held by those parts.
Best for: Complex PTSD with specific traumatic events
IFS + Somatic
How it works: Use IFS to dialogue with parts while tracking body sensations and allowing somatic release.
Best for: Fragmentation with body-held trauma
EMDR + Somatic
How it works: Use EMDR for memory processing while incorporating body awareness and somatic techniques for regulation.
Best for: PTSD with significant body symptoms
All Three
How it works: Use IFS for parts work, EMDR for memory processing, and Somatic for body release - integrated as needed.
Best for: Complex trauma requiring comprehensive approach
Key Takeaways
1. No Single "Best" Therapy
The best therapy depends on your trauma type, symptoms, and preferences. All three are effective.
2. IFS for Fragmentation
If you have parts or feel fragmented, IFS directly addresses this. Best for Complex PTSD.
3. EMDR for Specific Memories
If you have clear traumatic memories, EMDR is highly effective and relatively quick.
4. Somatic for Body Trauma
If trauma is held in your body or talking is difficult, Somatic therapy works through sensation.
5. Combination Is Possible
Many therapists integrate approaches. You don't have to choose just one.
6. Try What Resonates
Trust your gut. If one approach doesn't feel right, try another. All paths can lead to healing.